Photo Credit: Freepik.com

Identifying and Overcoming Toxic Workplace Culture: Key Signs and Effective Strategies

A toxic workplace can severely impact employee morale and productivity leading to disengagement, high turnover and financial losses. It is important to note that being able to recognise the signs of a toxic environment is essential for leaders and employers seeking to foster a healthier workplace. Let’s discuss further on how to identify the signs and what you can do to address these issues at a personal level.

Signs you work in a toxic work culture:

Disengagement and Negativity: In a research study that was conducted, it was found that only 36% of U.S workers are engaged at work leaving 50% disengaged and 15% actively disengaged. This disengagement tends to create a cycle of negativity that can permeate the workplace which is a huge cost to any economy annually in lost productivity. For example, a team member who consistently arrives lare or disrupts meetings with complaints can significantly affect overall morale and performance.

Role Confusion and Dysfunction: Unclear roles can lead to anxiety and conflict among team members. When Employees are unsure of their responsibilities in the organization, it can result in overlaps and misunderstandings. For instance, if two team members believe they are responsible for the same project, it may lead to tension, confusion, conflict and reduced collaboration. It is important to remember that clear communication of roles and expectations is crucial to mitigate the issue.

Chronic Stress: Employees often experience excessive stress due to heavy workloads, unclear expectations or conflict with colleagues. This chronic stress can lead to burnout and decreased productivity. For example, a worker feeling overwhelmed may avoid asking for help, compounding their stress and affecting their performance.

Pervasive Office Gossip: It is important to note that gossip thrives in toxic environments, breeding distrust and distractions. For instance, if an employee spreads rumors about a colleague, it can lead to conflict and a breakdown in communication, further exacerbating a toxic atmosphere. This can establish a culture of open communication that can help combat this behavior.

High Turnover Rates: Frequent employee turnover may indicate a toxic culture. A data from SHRM source reveals that one in five employees have left jobs due to workplace culture issues. High Turnover not only disrupts team dynamics but also incurs substantial recruitment and training cost.

Common Causes of a toxic work culture:

1. Poorly Defined Core Values: Without clear values, employees may feel lost and unaligned with the company’s mission. 

2. Inconsistent Expectations: Frequent Changes without support can lead to confusion and frustration among staff.

3. Unclear Communication: A lack of transparent communication channels can cause misunderstandings and disengagement.

4. Rampant Bullying and Cliques: Bullying reduces psychological safety, leading to mental health issues and burnout.

5. Emphasis on output Over people: Focusing solely on productivity can alienate employees and diminish their commitment.

Cost of Toxic Work Environment:

The financial implications of a toxic workplace are staggering. Research shows that toxic culture has cost businesses turnover over the last five years. Furthermore, a toxic environment diminishes productivity, with employees in negative settings up to 40% less productive than those in positive settings. Chronic Stress can lead to severe health issues, including depression and anxiety.

Strategies to Combat a toxic Culture:

1. Prioritize People: Fostering a people-culture can significantly enhance employee morale. Engaging employees in conversations about their needs and barriers to success encourages a supportive environment.

2. Regular Check in: Frequent Check-ins help to build trust and allow employees to voice concerns. Those who meet with their managers weekly are twice as likely to trust them and feel connected to their work.

3. Role Model: Leaders must embody the cultural values they wish to instill in their team members. Please note, Providing training on how to maintain a healthy workplace can help leaders set the right tone.

4. Hire for Attitude:  When organizations hire, it is important that candidates with a positive attitude and strong communication skills are considered, as these traits can help create a more supportive environment.

5. Recognise and Reward: When Organizations implement recognition programs can enhance employee satisfaction and promote a culture of appreciation. Simple acts of gratitude can have a profound impact on morale.

6. Flexible Work Environments: Organizations offering flexibility in work arrangements can boost engagement and productivity. Employees who work in their preferred settings are significantly more likely to feel accomplished and connected.

We must understand that addressing toxicity in the workplace is not just about rectifying immediate issues but fostering a culture of respect, communication and support. By recognising the signs and cause of a toxic environment and implementing actionable strategies, organizations can create a healthier, more productive workplace that benefits both employees and the company.

– Urveez Kakalia and Krupa Abraham

Reference:

 1. https://www.workhuman.com/blog/toxic-work-culture-environment/

2. https://www.apa.org/topics/healthy-workplaces/toxic-workplace

3. https://tivazo.com/blog/effects-of-working-in-unhealthy-work-environment/

Further reading

Effects of a workplace intervention on daily stressor reactivity

Leger, K. A., et al., Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 2022

How prevalent is workplace mistreatment: A meta-analytic investigation

Dhanani, L. Y., et al., Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2021

Suffering in silence: Investigating the role of fear in the relationship between abusive supervision and defensive silence

Kiewitz, C., et al., Journal of Applied Psychology, 2016